We lift concrete for a living, so take this with that in mind. But a lift on a slab that should be replaced is a bad job for both of us, so here's how we actually decide.
Check yours in 30 seconds
Good candidates for lifting
- Slabs in one piece or a few large pieces.
- Sections that sank at a joint, a corner, the garage or the house.
- Patios and walks that now drain toward the house.
- Concrete that still looks good on top.
When replacement is the better call
- The slab is broken into many small pieces.
- Tree roots pushed it up. Lifting only goes up. (Pushed up by frost is fine to send in: we look at lifting the slabs around it to meet it.)
- The surface is badly scaled, spalled or crumbling and you'd replace it for looks anyway.
- You're changing the layout, widening the driveway or adding steps.
How damaged is too damaged? A 1–5 scale
Lifting fixes where a slab sits, not what shape it's in. This is the scale we use to grade a slab from photos. It's a judgment tool, not an industry standard.
| Grade | What it looks like | Liftable? | Usual plan |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Sound | Sunk or tipped, in one piece, surface tight | Yes | Lift, then seal the joints |
| 2. Cracked, still one unit | One tight crack, both sides at the same height | Yes, usually | Lift, then caulk the crack |
| 3. Two or three big pieces | A crack with a step in it; crack edges still sharp | Often, case by case | Lift each piece to match, then caulk |
| 4. Breaking up | Four or more pieces, crumbling crack edges, or deep flaking over most of the surface | Usually not | Replace this slab, often while lifting its neighbors |
| 5. Failing | Rubble, missing chunks, soil or rusting steel showing | No | Replace |
To count pieces, trace each crack with your finger. A piece only counts if cracks cut it off completely, edge to edge or crack to crack. A crack that stops partway doesn't make a new piece.
Borderline slabs
- One clean crack straight through. Often still liftable. Holes go on both sides and the halves come up together until the crack is flush. What tips it toward no: crumbling crack edges, a crack wide enough to swallow a finger, or a half that rocks freely.
- A snapped corner. Common on driveways and aprons where tires cross the edge. A big corner piece that's tight against the slab usually lifts with it. A small, loose one may need a concrete contractor to cut it out.
- In one piece, but the surface is flaking. Light scaling is lifted, then cleaned and sealed. With stones showing, lift it if height or slope is the real problem and expect the look to stay. Stones standing out across most of the slab usually means replace.
- High in February. A slab pushed up by frost can settle back by late May. Measure again after the thaw before deciding anything.
Replace one slab, lift the rest
Most properties aren't all one grade. Say a driveway is six slabs of 10 by 12 feet, 720 square feet in all. The slab at the apron is in five pieces, two others sank in one piece, and three are fine. Replacing everything at about $9–$20 per square foot comes to about $6,480–$14,400. Replacing only the broken 120 square feet works out to about $1,080–$2,400 at the same rate, though small pours often cost more per foot or carry a minimum. The two sunken slabs are lifted, and the three good ones stay put. The replacement rate is our estimate of the local range for tear-out and repour, from Green Bay contractor pricing we checked in November 2026; not a quote for your job.
When a new pour and a lift sit side by side, agree on the order before anyone starts. If the new slab goes in first, ask the crew not to pin it into slabs that still need lifting. If the lift goes first, the replacement crew has the right heights to pour to. Either way the new slab and the lifted ones have to meet flush and drain the same direction. We don't pour concrete, so the replacement comes from a concrete contractor.
Lift vs. replace, side by side
| Lift with foam | Tear out and replace | |
|---|---|---|
| Time | One visit, usually a few hours | Several days of work, then about a week before you can drive on it |
| Mess | 5/8″ holes, patched | Jackhammers, dump trucks, forms, torn-up lawn edges |
| Weight added | Foam weighs 2–5 lb per cubic foot | New concrete weighs about 145 lb per cubic foot, on the same soil |
| Waste | Nothing hauled away | A 10×10 slab, 4″ thick, is about 2½ tons of broken concrete |
| Looks | Your concrete, back where it was | New concrete rarely matches the old slabs next to it |
| The cause | Foam fills the voids; we seal the joints | A new slab on the same washed-out base can settle the same way |
Replacement timing is typical; a contractor's schedule and the weather can stretch it. New-concrete cure times from Concrete Network; foam and concrete weights from ArmorThane.
What each option costs
Around Green Bay, tearing out and repouring a driveway runs about $9–$20 per square foot, tear-out included. That's our estimate of the local range for tear-out and repour, from Green Bay contractor pricing we checked in November 2026; not a quote for your job. Our foam lifting averages $4–$10 per square foot with a $300 minimum, so on average lifting costs about half of replacing. The ranges overlap, though: a lift at the top of our range can cost as much as a low-end replacement. The table below is the national picture, and its replacement figure is for a sidewalk.
| Foam lifting | Mudjacking | Tear out and replace | |
|---|---|---|---|
| National cost per sq ft | About $5–25 | About $3–6 | About $13–26 (sidewalk) |
| Back in use | Same day | 24–48 hours before vehicles | About 24 hours to walk on, 7 days to drive on |
| Weight added to the soil | 2–5 lb per cu ft | 100–150 lb per cu ft | About 145 lb per cu ft of new concrete |
Replacing doesn't fix why it sank
Concrete sinks because the soil under it moved. A new slab poured on the same base, with the same open joints and the same downspout, tends to go the same way. Lifting fills the voids, and sealing the joints shuts off the water that made them.
Why lifting usually costs less
Replacement means demolition, hauling, forming, a new base, new concrete, finishing and days of curing, usually across several visits by a crew. Lifting is one visit, a small crew and a few hours, with no concrete to haul away or pour.
Selling soon? A level, sealed walk and driveway shows well and removes an easy inspection note, usually for less than new concrete.
Photos that settle lift or replace
- The overhead. Hold the phone straight down from as high as you can reach. This is the shot that counts the pieces.
- The step. A tape measure standing at the lowest edge or crack shows how far the slab has to come up.
- The crack edges. A close-up with a coin beside it. Sharp edges are good news; rounded or crumbling ones aren't.
- The low-sun shot. Early or late in the day, long shadows show how deep any flaking goes.
- A rock-test video. Film while you step on each piece and corner.
When the answer is replace, you'll hear which slabs and why, who to call instead, and what's still worth lifting so you only replace what's done. Questions to ask before replacing concrete helps with the contractor.